In long-suffering Afghanistan, this is a peace offer worth trying

In long-suffering Afghanistan, this is a peace offer worth trying

Barnett R. Rubin is a senior fellow and associate director of the Center on International Cooperation and directs the Center’s Afghanistan-Pakistan local program.

This agreement can start a process that is the best chance to end Afghanistan’s 40- year war. It satisfies the core demands of the original antagonists of that war’s most current stage: the withdrawal of U.S. troops for the Taliban and assurances versus harboring terrorists for the United States. Next would come negotiations in between the fans of the Afghan Islamic republic and the Taliban on conditions to end their war, even as the fight against worldwide terrorists continues.

The contract supplies a timetable for troop withdrawal, counterterrorism guarantees, a path to a cease-fire and a procedure for political settlement. Implementation would also require dismantling Taliban facilities in neighboring Pakistan and assurances by external powers that none will utilize Afghanistan versus others.

The United States and advocates of Afghanistan’s Islamic republic fear that the Taliban might exploit a troop withdrawal to seek a military victory, while the Taliban fears that its concessions may demoralize its fighters and make it possible for the United States to hold off troop withdrawal. The contract overcomes skepticism by sequencing the elements and mentioning that all are synergistic. As each step is implemented, the parties will keep an eye on compliance prior to taking the next action.

Upon statement of the contract, both sides will devote to an across the country “ reduction in violence” for 7 days. The Taliban has made an outstanding offer of substantial and long lasting reductions in violence across the country that cover both Afghan and U.S.-coalition forces. The United States would reciprocate with a halt of offensive operations.

If both sides keep their word, they will sign the contract in Doha, as the U.S. and Afghan governments jointly state assistance for the procedure. The United States will reaffirm that it recognizes only that government as the nation’s legitimate sovereign.

The Taliban will clearly promise not to allow al-Qaeda in Afghanistan. The Taliban will also devote itself to continue to combat the Islamic State. An annex develops a center where the U.S. military and the Taliban will share counterterrorist info and monitor possible violations.

In the very first 135 days after finalizing, the United States will reduce its troops in Afghanistan to 8,600, about the force level at completion of the Obama administration. Beyond that, the contract conditions even more withdrawals on the Taliban meeting its counterterrorist commitments. The Taliban will stop attacks versus U.S. forces to help with the withdrawal. The United States reserves the right to help defend Afghan forces.

Within 10 days, the Taliban will open negotiations with the Afghan government and others who support the Islamic republic. The very first program product is most likely to be a comprehensive cease-fire. Government fans with whom I have actually spoken here in Kabul expect the Taliban to ask for an interim government including all parties in return for the cease-fire. That interim federal government might preside over a transition that would include modifications of the existing constitution.

A settlement would likewise need demobilization or integration of armed Taliban into the security forces. That is hard enough in any armed dispute, but in Afghanistan, it has actually the added trouble of requiring the demobilization of fighters and taking apart of military and terrorist facilities on both sides of the Afghanistan-Pakistan border. This requires the cooperation of Pakistan, and high-level military talks have actually begun.

Some oppose the procedure, arguing that the Taliban would never implement such an arrangement, that it is devoted to restoring its Islamic Emirate which Pakistan will never close down the Taliban safe house. This arrangement manages those dangers by enabling the United States and Afghan federal government to check the Taliban and Pakistan without foreclosing alternatives. The United States schedules the right to modify the withdrawal timetable to assure that all sides comply.

The Taliban will require a minimum of the right to participate in the federal government and changes to line up the current system more closely with its interpretation of Islamic law. That involves dangers to gains in human rights, specifically for females. The United States and its allies must stay engaged to assure that any such shift does not endanger the stability of the state and security forces and keeps the fundamental social gains of the past twenty years. according to Human Rights Watch, since 2016, kids have actually accounted for nearly one-third of the (most likely underestimated) 11,000 civilian casualties here every year. Which means the war to avoid another 9/11 causes another 9/11 on Afghan children every year it continues.

That toll stops working the test of proportionality.

The United States does not require to station troops in Afghanistan to defend itself from terrorism. The attacks of 9/11 were prepared in Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia, and Hamburg, not Afghanistan, where the leader who authorized the operation tricked his hosts about his actions. Today, such preparation might occur in dozens of countries. As new powers rise, the United States needs not to expand its military footprint however establish networks of cooperation versus common risks. The support for this procedure by China, Russia, Pakistan and Europe reveals it is possible. Protecting gains from this procedure will require further diplomatic initiatives with these countries. It needs to likewise avoid fight with Iran, perhaps the single most significant danger to this process. The administration might deal with choices in between exiting Afghanistan responsibly and challenging the nation’s neighbors. As it says in the Koran, “There are signs for those of understanding.”

Read more:

Learn More